Here is an incredibly good article I read this morning and had to share. I’ve experienced first hand how this type of ‘float’ or ‘kiting’ can ruin an honest small business by drying up its hard earned cash flow. Groupon, a company whose concept I totally believed in until I read this excellent investigative article, is doing the same thing to Investors and customers that Mayor Vincent ‘Buddy’ Cianci did to Rhode Island contractors.
Here is a comment that I left the author of the article below:
This article was beyond good! Thank you! I’d like to add that little do many taxpayers know, but many administrators of cities and towns, like the infamous Mayor Vincent “Buddy” Cianci, twice convicted felon, and longest serving Mayor of Providence, Rhode Island, make their money “on the float” as well. There is much cash to be had by these crooks, when they receive revenue from accounts and trusts that cover expenses to maintain parks, and plow streets then “park” the money somewhere (and pocket the juice) as they leave the hard working contractors waiting months to receive the money they earned for doing the work. I was a RI contractor who was burned this way. From a forensic accounting perspective, this form of embezzlement is tough to prove, because the money doesn’t actually go ‘missing’ –It disappears but then re-appears… As dirty politicians make interest, yet destroy small businesses, while they keep it in ‘limbo.’
Is Groupon the Next Enron?
By Keith Fitz-Gerald, Chief Investment Strategist
Is Groupon the next Enron? … No. It’s worse.
Before the company even went public, there were signs that internal financial controls weren’t up to snuff.
Now I’m hearing refrains of “three blind mice” as “defrauded” investors line up to have their day in court. You might as well say the “dog ate my homework.”
It’s not like no one knew this was coming.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) made management redo Groupon’s financial statements and accounting practices not once, but twice before the company’s January 2011 initial public offering (IPO).
The first time involved including the cost of marketing in operating income – duh. The second was to force the company to deductmerchant payments from revenues – double duh!
Both are basic accounting principles.
If you spent $2 to gain $1 in orders you have to report that as a $1 loss if you’re dealing with cold, hard cash. Also, if you have $1 in merchant payments, you can’t count that as $2 in revenues, unless apparently you work at Groupon and love accrual accounting.
It’s not like Groupon execs can claim they didn’t know.
It’s abundantly clear to me that the “company” has very little, if any, understanding of REG FD and securities litigation.
(REG FD, in case you are not familiar with it, is short for Regulation Fair Disclosure which the SEC adopted Aug. 15, 2000. REG FD is intended to eliminate selective disclosure of material non-public information.)
But I have a hunch they’re going to find out the hard way.
Groupon’s “Material Weakness”
When the SEC came knocking again on April 2nd the company was forced to restate its Q4 financials. That summarily reduced Groupon’s revenue by $14 million and profits – assuming there were any to begin with – by $22.6 million.
In an official statement, Ernst & Young, the company’s primary auditor, noted “material weakness” with regard to the company’s internal controls. Investors simply noted that they’d better get going while the going was good.
Groupon’s share price tumbled 16.87% Monday alone and is down 55% from its peak.
- UH-OH: The SEC Is Looking Closely At Groupon, Says Report
- 2007 RI Housing Market Crash: All my fault
- (GRPN) (businessinsider.com)
- Groupon Slithers Away Friday Night $GRPN $FB $GOOG (financialskeptic.wordpress.com)
- Groupon: Where Were The Auditors? (forbes.com)
- Groupon: $208 million in cash, but owe merchants $290 million (coverboom.com)
- What does all the bad press mean for Groupon? (venturebeat.com)
- Shareholder flings class action lawsuit at Groupon (go.theregister.com)
- Watching Groupon’s IPO by the numbers (news.cnet.com)
- With stock price tumbling, shareholder lawyers see Groupon as juicy target (venturebeat.com)
- Groupon isn’t a hot deal anymore (rt.com)
- First You Screw Up, Then Lie and Finally Die (thestreet.com)