In Memory of: Eight Sailors Killed in Collision at Sea

By Martha Jette

bellnap 2014-02-19_1753While I am grateful to be a part of ‘Sea Stories,’ I hope you all agree that these stories cannot all portray the happy and fun events involved in Navy life. It just would not be realistic. What follows is one incident that haunts many a sailor to this day, including me ~Ron Burwell

The USS Belknap (CG-26) had just finished a long and hard NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation) exercise in November 1975. The Naval Striking and Support Forces link U.S. Maritime forces into NATO operations. Thus the Navy provides a standing force for United Nations operations worldwide by providing ships, submarines, aircraft and personnel when needed. Because of this arrangement, NATO exercises are held so they can work jointly when necessary.

The ship had just broken off from the task force, passed through the Strait of Messina and was headed back to Gaeta, Italy. The group continued east just past Sicily at about 23:45 hours when they started to get ready for night flight operations. The guided missile cruiser, the USS Belknap (CG-26) was assigned to move from picket ship (meaning the sailors maintained a watch) to aft (toward the stern or rear of the ship) of the aircraft carrier, the USS John F Kennedy (CV-67).

The USS Kennedy had just finished its NATO exercises as well, had a port call at Catania, Sicily and then traveled the Strait of Messina.

On November 22, the OOD (officer of the deck) aboard the Belknap made a fatal mistake. Instead of flanking port, increasing speed and swinging around, he turned to starboard and slowed to save time. As a result, the two ships collided and the Belknap’s superstructure ended up under the John F. Kennedy’s overhanging flight deck.

In the process, fuel lines were ruptured and gasoline spewed across the Belknap’s deck. The gas ignited and “blazed up” the Belknap’s port side. It is said that firefighters got the fire under control topside in about 10 minutes but a “receiving room below burned for several hours.”

Heavy smoke forced the “evacuation of all the carrier’s fire rooms,” forcing the ship to go “dead in the water.” On top of that, there was ammunition aboard the Belknap that began firing, sending “fiery fragments into the air.”

Because of the presence of nuclear weapons on board both ships, the commander of Carrier Striking Forces for the Sixth Fleet sent a secret nuclear weapons accident message (a “Broken Arrow”) to the Pentagon, warning of the “high probability that nuclear weapons aboard the Belknap (W45 Terrier missile warheads) were involved in fire and explosion but there were no direct communications with the Belknap at that time and no positive indications that explosions were directly related to nuclear weapons. An hour after the Broken Arrow message was sent the USS Claude V. Rickettes (DDG 5), alongside the BELKNAP fighting the fire, reported that BELKNAP personnel said “no radiation hazard exists aboard”.

Since this fire endangered the lives of the sailors, vessels operating with the John F. Kennedy pulled alongside with no regard for their own safety in an attempt to rescue them as those ammo fragments hit their boats as well. The guided missile destroyer USS Claude V Rickets (DDG-5) and the destroyer USS Bordelon (DD-881) pulled in close on either side with fire hoses to help put out the blaze. The frigate USS Pharris (FF-1094) also provided assistance.

With the sailors refusing to abandon their ship, only the seriously wounded were rescued. As a result, the Belknap lost seven sailors, with 23 men suffering serious injuries. Aboard the John F. Kennedy, Yeoman 2nd Class David A. Chivalette succumbed to smoke inhalation and two others suffered injuries from the fire.

Sailors who saw the Belknap afterward, said the superstructure was “nearly completely melted and destroyed down to the main deck level.” The Belknap was towed to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania where it was “decommissioned and rebuilt.”

However, as Ron Burwell stated: “The worst losses of all were the lives of the sailors who perished that day. R.I.P. my brothers.”

In addition to the Sailor, Yeoman 2nd Class David A. Chivalette, who died on the USS John F. Kennedy (CV-67), here are the names of the sailors who perished aboard the USS Belknap (CG-26)…We thank you for your service, and for making the ultimate sacrifice for our country:

MM1 James W. Cass  MM2 Douglas S. Freeman  EM2 Michael W. Kawola  DS3 Gerald A. Ketcham  STG3 Brent W. Lassen  FA David A. Messmer  DS2 Gordon T. St. Marie

Fatalities aboard the USS Belknap (CG-26) 22 November 1975
Click image to donate to the Wounded Warrior Project


Sea Stories

Military Forum

Yahoo Answers

Navy History  

Enhanced by Zemanta

10 responses to “In Memory of: Eight Sailors Killed in Collision at Sea

  1. Machinist Mate First Class, James W Cass, Born June 8, 1939, Died November 22, 1975, at 36 years old. Vietnam Veteran. Intered at Woodlawn Memorial Gardens, Norfolk City, Virginia. Source: find a…&

    James W Cass (1939 – 1975) – Find A Grave Memorial

  2. I was there that night. I was ignored by higher ranks. I seen the collision coming. I was working in the Aircraft control tower. I activated the flightdeck fire fighting system. I basiclly flooded the flightdeck with foam and water.

  3. Dennis Murrisky

    I was there that night. I was ignored by higher ranks. I seen the collision coming. I was working in the Aircraft control tower. I activated the flightdeck fire fighting system. I basiclly flooded the flightdeck with foam and water.

  4. Since Danny “The Count” Koker built a beautiful bike in memory of these sailors killed in the collision at the request of Mark Angle, the articles posted here have been getting a lot of views. *PLEASE* if any visitors have any biographical information on these fallen military men, please leave a comment, and I’ll get in touch. Thanks!

  5. Thomas Fortin FTG2

    at the time i was an FTG aboard the USS Dale (CG19). about midnight (my recollection) I was on the fantail having a midrats coffee and smoke break. we were (by my estimation) about 3 to 4K yards from the Kennedy on her starboard quarter. Too far to accurately observe the maneuvers of the Kennedy and Belknap, yet i did observe the actual collision of the two vessels. the actual fire and damage didn’t present themselves immediately, but perhaps 10 to 15 minutes later the damage began to show itself. we (the USS Dale) were assigned to be the “hospital” ship that night. i also recall the Russian frigate that had been trailing us for several days pulled close along the Belknaps starboard side and commenced firefighting operations on her. that she only lost 7 men seems miraculous to one who could personally see the damage to her, especially by first light of the next morning when her damage became clear.. the sailor on the Kennedy who lost his life is undoubtedly one of the most unfortunate / unlucky sailors of the 6th fleet.

  6. EN2 Ellis Smith

    This ship was brought to Rota Spain and placed near the USS Simon Lake AS 33 Submarine Tender. The Damage Control Party went aboard.

    • Do you have any information about the Damage Control Party that went aboard in Rota? I would love to have any information about that! Thanks

  7. I was on jfk age 17 fresh out A school in Lakehurst NJ. I saw some of the guys who got burned. Was new so I didn’t know anyone yet . Not a good way to start a career . My heart Geo’s out to all the guys and their families. I’ll never forget it .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s